Okay, so I've been noticing that this community has been a little dead lately and that's been bugging me. I figured I'd try and liven this place up with a series or more or less regular posting about the "L".
Now that the CTA has finished rebuilding the Ravenswood (Brown Line--please, let's not got into this discussion again) the Authority is now turning its attention to the other North Side stations (namely Sheridan, Wilson, Lawrence, Argyle, Berwyn, Bryn Mawr, Thorndale, Granville, Loyola, Morse, Jarvis) and to stations in Evanston (South Blvd., Main, Dempster, Foster, Noyes, and Central). According to the website, the public comment period ended yesterday but I'm curious as to what the thoughts and opinions are of the people in this community regarding the rebuilding of these stations.
Let me begin by saying that I have no idea why Granville and Loyola are included as they are already ADA compliant, just as Howard and Davis are. (Note that Howard and Davis were not on CTA's list.) But nevermind that. On to the rebuilds!
As much as I am a fan of history and historical preservation, looking at this purely from an operational standpoint I'd have to say that Sheridan should go. Instead, a new station would be built at Irving Park (only a couple hundred feet west) in a similar fashion to what they did with Addison back in the early 90's. (Inserting a platform between the four track by adding two modern tracks and removing two old ones.) Without the local/express service (which has been gone since the 1940's) the dual platforms at Sheridan are no longer needed. Additionally, with the platforms out of the way, the tracks could be realigned for smoother curves through the S allowing for higher speeds.
I'd also want some stations picked out for historical preservation (not like the "preservation" done at Damen or Diversey). I'm thinking similar in nature to what was done at Ashland/Lake. Main, and Central are a must in my book. Dempster is virtually identical to Main, but is in worse shape and is less used. Foster and Noyes were never completed. They were supposed to get station houses like South Blvd. and Central, but it never materialized. (It'd be nice if they could become accessible with Arthur Gerber style station houses added, but we all know that's just not going to happen.)
Wilson, I'm sure, will have some level of preservation and I'd hope a few of the others would also get the same treatment. Thorndale, for instance. I'd also like to see the the auxillury exit at Bryn Mawr preserved as well.
On the whole, I think most should just be rebuilt as modern stations. Lawrence anybody?